Often the most in-depth analysis of a topic will be available in a book. While reference sources introduce a topic more broadly, the material in books will be more focused. Books may be intended for the general public or for an academic/scholarly audience. Here is a chart to help differentiate between scholarly and popular books.
Popular vs. Scholarly Books
| criteria |
Scholarly books & eBooks |
Popular books & eBooks |
| author |
Scholar, researcher, professor |
Journalist, political pundit, professional writer |
| publisher* |
University press or academic publisher |
Popular press such as Random House, or Hachette |
| language |
Discipline-specific vernacular, detailed & nuanced |
No expertise is expected, language is introductory |
| audience |
Scholars and students in a specific discipline |
General public |
| purpose/use |
Advance research/ contribute to a discipline |
Entertain or inform, sell product, promote a perspective |
| evidence/sources |
Index, footnotes or bibliography, extensive use of primary evidence |
May or may not include references, which may or may not be primary evidence |
*Self-published books may be intended as either academic or popular works. With no publisher claiming responsibility, requiring fact-checking, or providing editing the quality of self-published titles varies wildly. Use extreme caution.