OC logo

OC Libraries

Skip to main content
It looks like you're using Internet Explorer 11 or older. This website works best with modern browsers such as the latest versions of Chrome, Firefox, Safari, and Edge. If you continue with this browser, you may see unexpected results.

Evaluating Print (Non-Web) Sources: At First Glance...

At first glance...

Do a quick analysis of the material by looking for the author, publisher, and date of publication.  You may need to do a couple of searches on the author and/or publisher to make sure that you uncover any possible issues that aren't immediately apparent just from looking at the material.  For example, if a book is self-published by the author, it may be missing the high level of editing that is inherent in the corporate or academic publishing process.

Author analysis

·         Who is the author or authors?

·         If no author is listed, who is responsible for the material?

·         What are the author’s qualifications?

o   Does the author have an advanced degree in this subject/field?

o   What organizations does the author affiliate with?

o   What else has the author written?

o   What is the author’s reputation?

 

Publisher analysis

·         Who is the publisher?

·         What type of publisher is it?

o   Academic/University press

o   Popular press

o   Vanity press / self-published

·         Does the publisher have a reputation for publishing materials with a certain viewpoint?

 

Currency

·         When was the material published?

·         Is the information current or outdated?

o   Do you need current or historical information for your paper?

o   Is it a seminal/important works in your field that you should know about, regardless of date?

·         If there are multiple editions of the material, do you have the current edition?