Once you've generated your rubrics for an assignment, a paper or for the entire course, you need to evaluate them. Two frequently used techniques are:
RUBRIC FOR RUBRIC (Created by Marlene Biseda and Ariana Brooks)
CATEGORY |
4 |
3 |
2 |
1 |
0 |
Rubric Categories Uniqueness |
Rubric has unique assessment categories. |
Most of the assessment categories (>50%) are unique but a few overlap with others. |
Some of the assessment categories (about 50%) are unique but some overlap with others. |
Few of the assessment categories (<50%) are unique; most overlap with others. |
Rubric categories are not unique and overlap each other. |
Rubric Category Objectives |
Assessment categories account for all tasks and subtask objective factors of the learning experience. |
Assessment categories account for most of the relative factors of the learning experience. |
Assessment categories account for some of the relative factors of the learning experience. |
Few assessment categories account for the relative factors of the learning experience. |
Assessment categories do not account for all relevant factors of the learning experience. |
Rubric Category Assessment Criteria |
Assessment criteria for each category are clearly defined. |
Assessment criteria for most of the categories (>50%) are clearly defined. |
Assessment criteria for some of the categories (about 50%) are clearly defined. |
Assessment criteria for few of the categories (<50%) are clearly defined. |
Assessment criteria are not clearly defined for any category. |
Rubric Category Importance/ Weight |
The relative importance/ weight of each category is identified. |
The relative importance /weight of most categories (>50%) is identified. |
The relative importance/ weight of some categories (about 50%) is identified. |
The relative importance/ weight of few categories (<50%) is identified. |
The relative importance/ weight is not identified for any category. |
Rubric Performance Scale |
Rubric scale clearly defines all levels of performance. |
Rubric scale clearly defines most levels of performance. |
Rubric scale clearly defines some levels of performance. |
Rubric scale clearly defines few levels of performance. |
Rubric scale does not clearly define levels of performance. |
Rubric Scale Differentiation |
Achievement at each level is clearly differentiated from that of the higher and lower levels. |
Achievement at most levels is clearly differentiated from that of the higher and lower levels. |
Achievement at few levels is clearly differentiated from that of the higher and lower levels. |
Achievement at few levels is clearly differentiated from that of the higher and lower levels. |
Achievement at each level is not clearly differentiated from that of the higher and lower levels. |
Rubric Scale Tone |
[Blank in original] |
[Blank in original] |
Scale labels and details are positive. |
Most scale labels and details are positive. |
Scale labels and details are negative. |
Richlin, Laurie. Blueprint for Learning : Constructing college courses to facilitate, assess, and document learning, 144.